TonkaFocus Reports on School Board Meetings
The School Board Meeting and Study Session summaries here are written by TonkaFocus members who attended the meetings, or in some cases, viewed the tape of the meeting. Click on dates or links in blue to read longer summaries. Red text denotes issues of particular concern to TonkaFocus - curriculum censorship, data privacy practices, etc. For more details on any of these meetings, please e-mail the editors at info@tonkafocus.org
September 20, 2007 Study Session - Continued discussion of 2007-08 Goals from previous meeting; again, the board could not finish; further discussion scheduled for Oct 4 study session.
September 20, 2007 Board Meeting - Adoption of Preliminary 2008 levy of $31,863,000; adoption of policies; report on class sizes, and presentation of SMART boards in classrooms.
September 6, 2007 Study Session - Board members expressed anger at Mr. Wenmark's distribution, via district e-mail to board members and district employees, of a resume of one of his employees, whom he was advocating the district interview, even though this individual had missed the application deadline. The district was in the process of making a job offer to an individual who had gone through the district's established hiring practices; Mr. Wenmark criticized this person as a poor choice for the position. Dr. Peterson, Erin Adams and Judy Erdahl pointed out that Mr. Wenmark had violated data privacy practices, putting the district in jeopardy of legal action. Mr. Wenmark disagreed, then stated that his e-mail was being "eavesdropped" upon; Judy Erdahl explained that she requested all e-mails concerning the matter be captured on the district server to protect the district in case of future legal trouble, pointing out that everything collected was public record. Mr. Wenmark said he was very upset by this, but was ready to move on. The Board spent time discussing 2007-08 Goals, but did not finish.
September 6,
2007 Board Meeting - Report on
enrollment and staffing from opening of
school; report on use of technology;
presentation of new district web site to
be launched end of September.
April 19, 2007 Board Meeting -
Discussion of Elementary Language
Immersion and Q-Comp.
February 1, 2007 Board Meeting - Board member Peggy Stefan responded to comments made on December 5, 2006 by Mark Chalupsky, President of Minnetonka Teachers' Association (teachers' union) who wondered if the district has evaluated the change from 7 period days to 6 period days at secondary schools.
December 21, 2006 Board Meeting This summary covers discussion on
Community Comments on the proposed health model, the district's
communications about same, Board Chair response to comments, presentation of
budget projections, 6-1 vote on high school health model change, 7-0
vote to continue researching Highly Gifted elementary model, 7-0 vote in
favor of immediate enhancement of High Potential programs at elementary
and middle schools, 7-0 vote to offer Spanish or Chinese language immersion
at all elementary schools next year, two changes to 2006-07 school
calendar to accommodate Q-Comp training.
Go
here to read Chair Erin Adams' response to public comments of December 5th & 7th.
December 5, 2006 Study session
Discussion about Pre-IB and Pre-AP
models at middles schools;
Mr. Wenmark
objects to IB on ideological grounds.
Discussions on high school heath
education model and 7 period day at
secondary schools.
Ed: note,12-8-06:
correction
to report on 7 period day; links added.
November 30,
2006 Board meeting Summarized here are the 11/30 discussions re: High
Potential, MHS Health & Elementary Language Immersion
November 16, 2006 Study Session Discussion on India Partnership: Peace through Understanding; discussion of legislative position statements
May 4, 2006 - Regular School Board Meeting. Present were Adams, Langseth, Litsey, Maes, Stefan and Wenmark; Judy Erdahl is still on leave for health reasons. The Board reviewed textbooks for K-5 Social Studies, 8th grade Minnesota history, 9th grade U.S. Government, Economics & Geography, Psychology, higher algebra and pre-calculus; books are available to the public for two weeks at the District Service Center, after which the Board will vote on them. The Board heard reports from Minnewashta Elementary, a presentation on student technology use and discussed possible new courses or deletions at MHS; they also heard about the Minnetonka Community Ed program for adult English language learners, including visits with residents from Colombia, Azerbaijan, Afghanistan. To read the district's summary, go here
April 20, 2006 - The School Board considered the following items at a
Study Session at 5:00; present were
Board members Langseth, Litsey, Maes,
Stefan & Wenmark; absent Erdahl & Adams:
recommended improvements to middle and high
school guidance and counseling, with
recommendations from middle and high
school principals to be discussed in May; report
on NWEA pilot testing results, which
tailor computer tests to each student's
level; elementary
school surveys, showing a high level of
satisfaction with Minnetonka Schools,
but room for improvement in
communicating classroom learning to
parents and use of BlackBoard; subcommittee
(Maes, Stefan, Wenmark) report on
the Board's protocols and policies (code
of conduct) - board members were given a
draft for comments and questions; the
issue will be revisited May 18.
School Board Meeting:
Diamond Club baseball project operating
agreement and financing plan approved
5-0, but the board asked for changes to
restrictive covenants regarding use of
the fields by baseball and football; policies about
summer school, assignment of students to
schools were approved 5-0.
To see the
district's summary, go
here
To see the official
minutes, go
here
April 6, 2006 -
Calvin Litsey took the oath of
office and joined board members Adams,
Langseth, Maes and Stefan in discussion
about the updates for several school
district policies; the board voted
unanimously 5-0 to adopt an agreement
with the Minnetonka Teachers' Assoc.
meant to alleviate some workload issues
related to budget reductions; Dr.
Peterson outlined some possibilities for
high school students to receive credit
outside the 6 period day, with details
to be ready before students begin
registering April 26.
To see the
district's summary, go
here
To see the official
minutes, go
here
March 23, 2006 -The School Board appointed Calvin Litsey to fill the vacancy left by Dave Eaton's resignation; Mr. Litsey will take the oath of office at the April 6 meeting. Vote: Adams, Langseth, Maes, Stefan - Yes; Wenmark - No. Board members had high praise for the 13 individuals who applied, said our community is fortunate to have so many people willing to serve, and expressed the hope that some will consider running for election in 2007.
March 16, 2006 -
Study Session: Chairperson Erin
Adams read a letter from Judy Erdahl
explaining her need for an
extended leave of absence from the
Board for medical treatment.
The Board reviewed several more
instructional models for elementary
and middle school: environmental studies
magnet, Montessori magnet, continuous
progress, high potential magnet,
International Baccalaureate,
math/science magnet - they agreed to
meet soon for a work session with
administrators to narrow the list to any
they might want to pursue for further
analysis.
Charlie Hurd outlined new building
plans of District 287 (a
collaboration serving many levels of
special needs learners from several
local school districts).
Mike Cunningham of the Booster Club
brought two student interns who
presented the Board with a check for
$32,000 from fundraising. Dr. Dennis
Peterson presented his report on the
impact this school year of $3.2 million
budget cuts made in February 2005 -
actual total saved was $3.8 million,
with $600,000 going to necessary
staffing, mostly at MHS, which would
have been an expense anyway - he will
present more information in April and
May about student progress and class
sizes and recommend the Board look again
at spending in some areas - Bill Wenmark
asked about keeping/expanding the MHS
work experience, where students receive
diploma credit for work instead of
classroom experience, ensuing discussion
about mastering benchmarks and standards
in the classroom and their value to
diploma, Dr. Peterson expressed desire
to provide students with the "meat and
potatoes" behind the diploma and said
they will continue to monitor the work
experience program -
Bill Wenmark
protested that although the 6 period day
achieved dollar savings, he hears from
many parents and teachers unhappy with
it - Dr. Peterson defended the budget
decision to go from 7 to 6 periods and
said if we hadn't, finances would have
required eliminating many programs and
increasing class sizes by 5-8 students,
both things the Board did not want
- he
said the average student course load
went down only slightly, they are still
working on details in next weeks to help
students manage schedules for next year
- Bill Wenmark argued that people
objecting to higher class sizes was
speculation and people should be asked
now how they feel about it - Erin Adams
pointed out it was a structural decision
made by the Board because they couldn't
afford to provide quality education at 7
periods any longer - Dr. Peterson noted
it was the best choice of bad choices,
the district has worked on scheduling
alternatives for students and is
committed to helping everyone adjust to
6 periods - Peggy Stefan asked if kids
might be less stressed taking 6 classes
instead of 7 and noted we can't fully
evaluate after 8 months but no one
reacts well to having things taken away
- Dr. Peterson said principals at middle
school and high school are talking about
ways to adapt, this is new and evolving
- Pam Langseth urged communications to
parents - Dr. Peterson said the
intention is to have options in place by
April when kids will finish registration
- Bill Wenmark asked whose idea it was
to go to 6 hour day - Dr. Peterson said
it was his leadership decision, after
looking at several possible solutions,
and based on the reality that we don't
get enough revenue under MN law to
sustain the programs we had two years
ago, the principals involved looked at
changing models as part of their
responsibility to come up with budget
reductions in keeping with the Board's
vision - staff was asked for input but
wasn't asked to make decisions because
most employees don't want to eliminate
other employee's jobs - Dr. Peterson
restated that the decision was one of
administrative leadership when the Board
instructed him to make recommendations -
he noted negative impact on music
program, possibility of killing the
program if cuts stay as is, recommends
review of this - World Language program
in 8th grade has potential for very
positive impact.
Bill Wenmark said there was a big
problem with parent e-mail
instead of regular mail and he'd bring
up discussion in Board meeting.
The Board heard a report by Children
and Family Support Program, a
partnership of early childhood
educators, early special ed, social
workers and others who help families
prepare kids for school success.
Citizen Input - A district
resident, Mr. Greenfield, spoke to the
Board about concerns he raised in
Dec 2004 about a political rally at MHS which he felt weren't addressed.
Chair Erin Adams apologized, saying she
thought he'd resolved the issue with
Carol Eastlund at the time. Mr.
Greenfield wondered how much control the
district has over the ArtsCenter
auditorium (under joint agreement with
City of Minnetonka) during the school
day and how that might affect the school
environment. Dr. Peterson explained they
were asked to host the President of the
U.S., it wouldn't have been appropriate
to refuse, and later found that Rudy
Guiliani, "an American hero" was coming
instead; the building principal, Dave
Adney, made decision about educational
value, History teachers were given an
opportunity to bring some students who
wanted to attend. Erin Adams said a
political rally has an educational
component and she wished another party
had offered one as well. Peggy Stefan
said she'd expect our principals to
offer that educational opportunity to
our students if it came up.
March 16, 2006 - Board Meeting
The Board gave permission to
Minnetonka Diamond Club to solicit bids
for the baseball project,
concurrently with approval process with
City of Minnetonka. The Board's agenda
had several policies to be reviewed
after updating by the school district's
attorney; because of the late hour, they
decided to look at only two. A few
wording changes were asked for in the
Advertising policy.
Bill Wenmark
again raised what he described as his
legal concerns with parent e-mail
addresses and spoke at great length
about why he believes parent e-mail
addresses should be public information.
Board members and Dr. Peterson
vehemently disagreed with this, and at
several points, they emphasized that the
district has never regarded e-mail
addresses as public, and that great
efforts are made to protect privacy. Mr. Wenmark
agreed that this is so; but he continued
to insist that the district wasn't in
compliance with paperwork proving this,
and therefore was at risk for financial
penalties. Other Board members and Dr.
Peterson stated their intention to
follow the school district's attorney's
legal advice. Mr.
Wenmark's motion to make parent e-mail
addresses public failed on a 1-4 vote;
later, the Board approved Policy
#515: Protection and Privacy of Pupil
Records on a unanimous vote.
(see
the official minutes here)
March 2, 2006 - Board Meeting: principals from MMW and Clear Springs explained initiatives at their schools designed to identify and serve struggling students before referral to Special Ed; the Board approved the calendar for school year 2006-07 as presented by a district committee - a major change is one Oct. 9 conference day from 8 a.m. - 6 p.m. with six additional hours to be scheduled by building; the Board reviewed several policies updated by their attorney - Bill Wenmark raised what he said were his many legal concerns about a Data Practices policy and strongly urged that parent e-mail addresses be public information - the Board and administration expressed no need or desire to make those public - the issue was tabled for future discussion; bids were approved to update 8 science classrooms in the next two years; Bill Wenmark asked to be excused from service to the Minnetonka Family Collaborative, citing lack of time due to his business and his thought that someone with more financial accountability was needed - Cathy Maes offered to serve - Chairperson Erin Adams asked Mr. Wenmark to consider committing time to another committee, since he now serves on none. Go here to see the district's (see the official minutes here)
February 17, 2006 - Special Meeting to discuss procedures for
filling school board vacancy.
(see the official minutes here)
February 16, 2006
Six Board members present Possible
plans for elementary or middle school
instructional models were presented: a
Spanish immersion school and a high
potential academy; 5-6 other possibilities
will be presented at future meetings; the
Board has yet to decide whether or not any
changes are desirable. The preliminary plans
by the Diamond Club community baseball
supporters to remodel a baseball stadium on
the MHS campus were approved; details yet to
be worked out include restrictions on
advertising and closer collaboration with
soccer and softball programs. To see the
District summary, go
here
(see the official minutes here)
February 2, 2006 Six Board members present. Minnetonka
School Board Member David Eaton resigned on January 31, 2006, effective
immediately, citing personal reasons. Mr. Eaton led the recent unsuccessful
effort to introduce intelligent design concepts into the Minnetonka science
curriculum and was defeated in his bid to continue as the Board's Treasurer. Mr.
Eaton was appointed to fill a vacancy on the Board in 2002 and was elected
unopposed in 2003.
To
see the District's summary of this meeting, go
here
To read the Treasurer's Report by Board Treasurer Peggy Stefan, go
here
(see the official minutes here)
January 31 - Minnetonka School Board Member David Eaton resigned, effective immediately, citing personal reasons. Mr. Eaton led the recent unsuccessful effort to introduce intelligent design concepts into the Minnetonka science curriculum and was defeated in his bid to continue as the Board's Treasurer. Mr. Eaton was appointed to fill a vacancy on the Board in 2002 and was elected unopposed in 2003; his contributions to the district include technology planning and the Dome project.
January 19, 2006 - Study Session and School Board
Meeting. Board member Eaton absent; all others present. At the Study Session,
the Board: reviewed the NWEA test; reviewed an analysis of the MnSCU report on
post-high school math; heard an update on technology implementation; reviewed
the Professional & Technical Writing textbook; heard a report by the
sub-committee reviewing tools and procedures of the Superintendent's evaluation.
During the Board meeting, they: agreed a sub-committee of Peggy Stefan,
Bill Wenmark and Cathy Maes should look into Mr. Wenmark's concerns raised Jan 9
and report back to the Board for action to be taken by April 1; discussed a
school visit schedule; had first reading of policies on out-of-state travel.
To read the official minutes, go
here
January 9, 2006 Regular School Board
Meeting All members present. Board Members Adams, Langseth & Maes take oath of office; Adams is
re-elected to Chair, Erdahl to Vice Chair;
Stefan is elected new Treasurer, replacing
Eaton; Langseth elected Clerk, replacing retired
member Eastlund. Mr. Wenmark expressed his
displeasure at the Board's seating arrangements and requested agenda changes on
items about the Board's code of conduct, meeting protocols, agenda development,
Board leadership benchmarks and e-mail procedures; the Board agreed to table
these items and look into a sub-committee to address these issues. The Board:
heard reports from Excelsior school, Middle School East, the Minnetonka
Foundation; Dan Sigurdson of the Finance Advisory and Audit Committee was
present to answer questions on the Legislative Positions statement, which the
Board adopted unanimously 7-0; accepted the proposed date of February 7 for the
Superintendent's mid-term evaluation; discussed the 2006-07 school year
calendar. Mr. Wenmark asked to add two documents to the minutes of the December
15 meeting which he said would correct the record on Ms. Eastlund's statement
concerning the Discovery Institute's Wedge strategy of Intelligent Design; his
second document concerned a citizen's complaint at the December 15 study session
about e-mail he and Mr. Eaton sent which the citizen felt was an inappropriate
threat of legal action; in both cases, the Board declined to amend the minutes.
To see the District's summary of this meeting, go
here
To read the official minutes, go
here
December 20 - Federal Judge
John Jones III ruled that the Dover,
Pennsylvania school district's endorsement of
Intelligent Design is unconstitutional.
"...the disclaimer singles out
the theory of evolution for special treatment,
misrepresents its status in the scientific
community, causes students to doubt its validity
without scientific justification, presents
students with a religious alternative
masquerading as a scientific theory, directs
them to consult a creationist text as though it
were a science resource, and instructs students
to forego scientific inquiry in the public
school classroom and instead to seek out
religious instructions elsewhere..."
To read a summary of
the court's decision, go
here
To read the full 139
page decision, go
here
December 15, 2005 Study Session and Special School Board Meeting Board Chair Adams absent; all other members present. (see the official minutes here) At the Study Session preceding this meeting, the Board agreed to vote on all of the science standards that evening; MHS Principal Dave Adney discussed options for weighted grades; a citizen made a complaint against Board members Eaton and Wenmark for their e-mail threatening legal action after the citizen expressed disapproval at their actions during the campaign - the citizen asked the Board to review the matter in the context of their Code of Conduct and Operating Principles. During Public Comments, 20 individuals spoke to the Board concerning the science standards, 13 in favor of keeping Minnetonka's standards intact, and 7 in favor of wording changes that would allow for intelligent design and related concepts, and weaken the teaching of evolution. Board Member Carol Eastlund read a prepared statement showing the connections between Intelligent Design and certain sects of Christianity. The Board voted 5-2 to retain existing science standards, which include teaching the theory of evolution as the explanation for the development and diversity of life on Earth over 3+ billion years The Minnetonka standards continue to require critical analysis of all scientific models and theories, but do not single out evolution as Mr. Eaton recommended. Although Mr. Eaton and Mr. Wenmark insisted the changes they favored were not about Intelligent Design, the vast majority of people who spoke, or who wrote to the Board - both for the changes and against them - recognized that this was indeed, about Intelligent Design.
December 1, 2005 Regular School Board
Meeting All members present. The Board heard school reports from
Scenic Heights and Excelsior; a report on the district's partnership with
Chinese schools presented by a visiting teacher from China; discussed the
proposed alignment of the district's science standards with the state standards.
(see the official minutes here)
Go
here
for a transcript of the December 1 science discussion.
November 17, 2005 Study Session and Special School Board Meeting All members present. The Board: heard and adopted the auditor's report unanimously 7-0; considered and adopted the co-curricular activities policy unanimously 7-0. (see official minutes here)
November 10, 2005 Canvass of Election Mr. Eaton absent; all other members present. The Board canvassed the election results of November 8; approved unanimously 6-0. (see the official minutes here)
November 3, 2005 Regular School Board Meeting Mr. Wenmark shares his thoughts on the election and criticizes TonkaFocus; TonkaFocus responds. (see official minutes here)
October 6, 2005 Regular School Board Meeting MME School Report; bond refinance saves $575,000; district's annual report; teacher contract approved; report on open enrollment; discussion of Operating Principles - Mr. Eaton and Mr. Wenmark object. (see official minutes here)
September 15, 2005 Study Session and Special School Board Meeting (see the official minutes here)
September 1, 2005 Regular School Board Meeting Tonka CARES; opening days of school, rise in enrollment; student test results; tax levy; discussion and vote on Minnetonka Youth Hockey Association; discussion re: public endorsement of candidates by Board members - Mr. Wenmark objects. (see the official minutes here)
August 18, 2005 Study Session and Special School Board Meeting (see the original minutes here)
August 4, 2005 Regular School Board Meeting (see the official minutes here)
July 7, 2005 Regular School Board Meeting (see the official minutes here) Vision/Strategic Plan report; adoption of Science texts - Mr. Eaton and Mr. Wenmark have comments on students discussing "current and controversial issues." Dome management agreement with Minnetonka Youth Hockey approved unanimously; Superintendent's evaluation.
June 16, 2005 Study Session and Special School Board Meeting Study session discussion re: progress on goals; Mini-School; MN Student survey; MHS Pier. Board meeting discussion on Aa1 bond rating; World Language texts adopted.
June 2, 2005 Regular School Board Meeting Discussion and decision regarding number and type of graduation credits.
May 19, 2005 Study Session and Special School Board Meeting Citizen comments in favor of IB; 5-2 vote to approve IB texts; Mr. Wenmark apologizes to public for his previous support of IB, saying he was at first excited about the curriculum but now sees that it "internationalizes" the school; policy on public viewing new texts, materials. The complete list of IB books includes award-winning literature such as 100 Years of Solitude by Colombian writer Gabriel Garcia Marquez, Beloved by American writer Toni Morrison, The Quiet American by English writer Graham Greene, Housekeeping by Iowa writer Marilyn Robinson. The list also contains a widely-used biology lab manual which covers both macro-evolution and micro-evolution.
May 5, 2005 Regular School Board Meeting Discussion of graduation credits; approval of World Language standards after Mr. Wenmark questions; Mr. Wenmark questions IB enrollment
April 21, 2005 Study Session
High Potential teacher
speaks against IB to the School Board, and later to a MN legislative committee.
April 21, 2005 Special School Board Meeting - No report filed.
April 7, 2005 School Board Meeting - No report filed.
March 17, 2005 Study Session and Special School Board Meeting - No report filed.
March 3, 2005 Regular School Board Meeting - No report filed.
February 24, 2005 Special School Board Meeting Citizens speak for and against IB; Board members Eaton and Wenmark move to cut IB; Board approves budget cuts; IB texts are approved 5-2. (see the official minutes here)
February 8, 2005 Regular School Board Meeting Three citizens speak against IB. (see the official minutes here)
January 20, 2005 Study Session and Special School Board Meeting - No report filed.
January 6, 2005
Regular School Board Meeting
Board
members Eaton and Wenmark raise ideological
objections to IB
(see the official minutes here)